Paul Thomas Anderson may finally be on his way to an Oscar win. His latest film, One Battle After Another, currently sits as his highest-rated work on Rotten Tomatoes, generating substantial Oscar buzz for Best Screenplay and Best Director. For PTA – a visionary filmmaker with an astonishing 11 Academy Award nominations but no wins – this really does feel like his moment to shine.
Many critics and audiences have long considered There Will Be Blood his crowning achievement, and One Battle After Another seems poised to inherit that throne. However, this visionary storyteller has a body of work that has become utterly iconic. And beneath the accolades and the anticipation lies a truth that devoted cinephiles have known for over two decades: Magnolia remains Paul Thomas Anderson’s true masterpiece. Here’s why.
Magnolia: Paul Thomas Anderson’s Portrait of Human Fragility
What makes Magnolia so enthralling is its unflinching examination of broken people seeking redemption. Not only that but the exploration of the ripple effect one person’s actions can have on those around them, even years after the fact. To that, this visionary filmmaker created a work of art that is almost impossible to not resonate with on some level. Paul Thomas Anderson effortlessly constructs a world where some of Los Angeles’ top players coincide with everyday people, showing us that the world is much smaller than we realize.
Dying television producers, former child prodigies, and caregivers orbit each other in patterns of pain and longing. Each character carries wounds – some self-inflicted, others inherited – and the film refuses to offer easy absolution for any of its arcs. Tom Cruise‘s Frank T.J. Mackey, a toxic masculinity guru hiding profound shame about his dying father, delivers one of cinema’s most devastating performances, building on the moving monologue from Jason Robards in the heart-wrenching scene before. Meanwhile, William H. Macy‘s Quiz Kid Donnie Smith stumbles through life seeking love in all the wrong places, his desperation palpable in every frame.
What Magnolia is proof of, is that Anderson understands human fragility isn’t weakness; it’s the fundamental condition of existence. At just 29 years old, he possessed the wisdom to show us that acknowledging our brokenness is the first step toward healing. In today’s landscape of increasing openness around mental health issues, this makes Magnolia all the more relevant even over two decades after its release.
Sheer Narrative Ambition Mastered
There’s no doubt about it, Paul Thomas Anderson has become renowned for his grand scale projects. While the production isn’t always so seismic, the story is sprawling, even if it is a simple tale. Out of so many epics, the structural audacity of Magnolia remains unmatched in his eclectic filmography. Weaving between nine major storylines across just over three hours of runtime could easily collapse into incoherence, yet Anderson conducts his epic symphony with resounding precision and pacing.
The film opens with a prologue about coincidence and fate, immediately establishing that we’re watching something ambitious and extraordinary. Soon enough, stories come together and lives intricately intersect, allowing Anderson to demonstrate his skill as a master evoker of emotion. The film’s central idea – that sometimes life is unexplainable and that meaning arises not from knowing everything but from accepting mystery – is embodied in the notorious frog segment, which some have mocked as ridiculous. But when you look at it deeper, Magnolia goes for the fences with unadulterated ambition, seeking to portray nothing less than the human condition itself.
The Precious Wisdom of Paul Thomas Anderson
As mentioned, what’s perhaps the remarkable achievement of Magnolia is the fact that Paul Thomas Anderson crafted the picture before he’d accumulated the life experience such thematic depth typically requires. At 29, most filmmakers are still finding their voice whereas Anderson was already speaking profound truths about regret, mortality, forgiveness, and the desperate human need for connection. The film’s recurring motif – “We may be through with the past, but the past ain’t through with us” – feels like something a much older artist would articulate after decades of reflection.
His decision to have the ensemble sing along to Aimee Mann‘s “Wise Up” mid-narrative shouldn’t work, yet it became one of cinema’s most emotionally honest moments. Anderson recognized that individuals don’t live their lives in tidy three-act patterns; instead, they endure chaos, seek purpose, fail repeatedly, and occasionally catch a glimmer of grace. With such accuracy behind its execution, Magnolia portrays this reality so profoundly that viewing it becomes more like witnessing life rather than a movie. So, while One Battle After Another may earn Paul Thomas Anderson his long-overdue Oscar recognition, Magnolia will endure as the film where his genius first fully revealed itself – imperfect, audacious, and utterly unforgettable.
Read Next: The Top 10 Movies of the 21st Century According to The New York Times
Follow Us
