Top 5 Underrated HGTV Shows

With the success of home improvement and design programs, several HGTV shows have received high ratings, while others have stayed underrated by television audiences. Launched 30 years ago on December 30, 1994, HGTV has been a staple network for a growing number of television audiences and fanbases. Every week, HGTV attracts over 10 million American homes to its shows.

HGTV has some of the most popular TV show hosts in home renovation and design television. Although some shows have fared well over others, it has arguably turned several of its hosts into celebrities. With an ever-growing list of shows to choose from, if new audiences relied solely on ratings, several quality HGTV shows would go unnoticed. Here are 5 HGTV shows underrated by critics and audiences.

Small Town Potential

HGTVs Small Town Potential

A good way to get started is with one of HGTV’s newer shows, Small Town Potential. Although it’s easy to group it with several similar shows on the network, Small Town Potential has lots of potential. The show premiered on the network on March 3, 2023, with an 8-episode season 1. Small Town Potential is hosted by host partners Davina Thomasula and Kristin Leitheuser. Based in the Hudson Valley, the show helps newcomers to upstate New York find a perfect home. 

With her real estate and home design skills, Thomasula helps find a befitting home and design a timeless renovation plan. The rest is left for her life partner Leitheuser, a certified contractor, and her dad to bring to life. The interesting thing about Small Town Potential is that viewers see new clients get amazing homes, as well as Davina Thomasula and Kristin Leitheuser’s personal and career lives.

Watch Small Town Potential on HBO Max

Down House Fab

HGTVs Down House Fab

Down House Fab is one of HGTV’s shows that was underrated in its first season. It holds a shocking 5.6/10 rating on IMDb. Hosted by Chelsea and Cole DeBoer, Down House Fab follows the couple’s renovation plans for prospective clients. They bring together individual expertise as a contractor and creative designers. Despite the show’s ratings, Down House Fab enjoyed increased viewership throughout season 1. Moreover, its success led to a renewal for season 2.

Watch Down House Fab on HGTV

Brother Vs. Brother

HGTVs Brother Vs Brother

With an IMDb rating of 6.4/10, Brother Vs. Brother is one HGTV show underrated by critics. Hosted by twin brothers Jonathan Scott and Drew Scott, Brother Vs. Brother saw each brother compete against each other, having a team of renovators, builders, and designers on a predetermined timeframe and budget. Real estate and appraiser experts would determine which property had the highest resale value at the end of the renovations.

Brother Vs. Brother aired for 8 seasons. If anything, that’s enough proof the show had a dedicated audience. Brother Vs. Brother is Jonathan Scott and Drew Scott’s third reality TV show together. Although mostly known generally for their Property Brothers franchise, Brother Vs. Brother is one of the twin brothers’ shows that is often underrated.

Watch Brother Vs. Brother on HGTV

My Lottery Dream Home

David Bromstad on HGTV's My Lottery Dream Home

Its shocking and surprising that the David Bromstad-hosted My Lottery Dream Home has an average rating of 6.7/10 on IMDb. Bromstad is one of HGTV’s most popular and celebrated show hosts. His My Lottery Dream Home helps new lottery winners that match their taste and bigger budgets. Besides giving audiences home tours to dream about, David Bromstad brings a lot of glamor and fun to every episode. With an ever-growing fan base throughout its successful 15 seasons, My Lottery Dream Home is still one of the HGTV shows often underrated by television audiences.

Watch My Lottery Dream Home on HGTV

Rock the Block

HGTVs My Lottery Dream Home

HGTV’s Rock the Block brought together four of the network’s experts to compete against each other. The mission is to renovate old houses with the best designs and compete to sell them for a profit. Besides watching old homes get new looks, watching each expert bring their unique style to each design makes the show a lot more fun.

Moreso, viewers get to watch the winning expert have a street named in their honor and walk away with the bragging right as the winner. Rock the Block season 5 premiered on March 4, 2024. Ignoring its 7/10 rating, Rock the Block is an exciting way to get started with HGTV or start a new show on the network. If you enjoyed reading about the 5 underrated HGTV shows, read 7 top interior design hosts On HGTV.

Watch Rock the Block on HGTV

Main Heading Goes Here
Sub Heading Goes Here
No, thank you. I do not want.
100% secure your website.