Every great movie has one non-negotiable attribute: compelling storytelling. This goes beyond simply having an interesting plot. It has to explore complex themes and make every scene essential to the message it’s trying to convey. Sometimes, viewers may not grasp the message when they’re watching the movie for the first time. Most of the time, it’s because they’re still trying to figure out who’s who and what’s happening.
But when they watch the movie a second time, everything they missed finally clicks into place. That’s exactly the case for these five movies. It’ll be quite egregious to simply see them as confusing movies that became less confusing on second viewing, because they’re not. Confusing movies don’t suddenly become less confusing, no matter how many times people watch them. Just ask anyone who has seen Primer at least a dozen times.
1. Arrival (2016)
The aliens were a nice touch, but they’re not the real story. This movie starts at the “end” and ends at the “beginning.” But most viewers didn’t catch that detail the first time. All those quiet moments with Louise (Amy Adams) and her daughter seem like sad memories at first. But on second viewing, it’s obvious they’re flash-forwards because Louise starts thinking like the aliens, all of time at once, not in a straight line.
So, every time she hugs her daughter or says something sweet to her, she knows how it all ends but chooses to love anyway. And that picture only comes into focus because the viewer is no longer as focused on the aliens as they likely were the first time around. It’s also worth pointing out that the film’s opening title card doesn’t appear until the very end.
2. Everything, Everywhere, All At Once (2022)
Anyone who watched this masterpiece just once probably dismissed it as another chaotic hot mess. And they’ll feel justified in doing so because that’s basically the feeling a movie with hot dog fingers, rocks with googly eyes, and a raccoon chef elicits. But those who watched it the second time know that all that multiverse noise is just hiding a very simple, sappy love story between Evelyn (Michelle Yeoh) and Waymond (Ke Huy Quan). That little googly eye he sticks on his sweater early on is his whole philosophy: see the good even when everything’s falling apart. And when Evelyn slaps one on her own forehead in the final fight, she’s finally getting it. It’s the same silly sticker, but it finally makes sense when you know where their hearts are headed.
3. Tenet (2020)
This is probably the best proof of how some movies don’t truly click until you watch them twice. Anyone watching Tenet for the first time likely spent the entire movie trying to figure out who’s going forward and who’s going backward. But the second time? Everything clicks because of one throwaway line. Near the end, just before Neil (Robert Pattinson) walks off to die, he looks at the protagonist and says, “For me, this is the end of a beautiful friendship.” The protagonist tells him that it’s just the beginning for him. First watch, it sounds like a cheesy Casablanca callback. But rewatch it knowing that Neil is really saying goodbye, since their friendship runs backwards for him, and that line goes from cheesy to heartbreaking in a flash.
4. Parasite (2019)
Watching Parasite for the first time feels like watching a fun con artist romp; everyone’s rooting for the Kim family, enjoying the ride, and laughing at their schemes. That laughter turns to dread when the flood hits and the basement door opens. On a rewatch, that smooth scholar’s rock (suiseki) given to the Kim family as a symbol of good fortune and wealth stops looking like the cute prop it looked like the first time. Even more so with the knowledge that it ends up as a murder weapon. And every time someone walks down the stairs, there’s this involuntary flinch from viewers who know that director Bong Joon Ho isn’t just showing a house. He’s showing a film that’s obsessed with who lives above and who lives below.
5. Malignant (2021)
Malignant is pretty straightforward the first time: spooky ghost lady, creepy visions, brutal murders, and all the standard haunted-house vibes viewers have come to expect from horror movies. Second time, though, two things jump out. One, the killer’s face is always hidden behind greasy hair. But that’s not a face, that’s the back of Madison’s (Annabelle Wallis) head. Because the killer, Gabriel, is literally attached to the back of her head. Two, that weird, jerky walk isn’t bad acting. He’s just moving backwards for the entire movie. Once that clicks, every early kill scene plays completely differently.
Follow Us
