Every actor retains the right to choose which movie they get to sign on to, and it’s normal to see one turn down an opportunity here and there. The reasons vary, from contract obligations to a pitch that doesn’t quite make sense at the time. Sometimes, though, the actor ends up watching from the sidelines as the project they turned down becomes a bigger hit than the one they chose instead.
These five stories span five decades, and each actor had their own reasons for saying no. But they all end the same way: the actor watching from the sidelines as someone else runs with the role. A few of the choices look stranger in hindsight than others, and one actor reportedly turned down a deal worth $450 million without thinking twice.
1. Will Smith – (The Matrix for Wild Wild West)

Will Smith sat down with the Wachowski brothers and listened to their movie pitch about trench coats, red pills, and a simulated reality. At the time, they just had one movie credit, Bound, which was a good movie but not exactly a blockbuster. But Smith heard them out nonetheless. When they were done, he basically said, “No, thanks,” because the story didn’t quite make sense to him. Instead, he signed up for Wild Wild West, an unmemorable Western where his character fights a mechanical spider.
That movie did more than flop. It swept the Razzies that year, winning five awards, including Worst Picture. The Matrix, on the other hand, hit theaters in 1999, pulled in roughly $473 million worldwide, and kicked off a remarkable franchise. Keanu Reeves became Neo, by the way, and Smith still catches flak for that call. To his credit, he’s owned it, admitting that he would have ruined Neo anyway. “Keanu was perfect,” he said. And he was spot on.
2. Burt Reynolds – (Pretty Woman for Modern Love)

Burt Reynolds is arguably the most infamous option on this list. The guy had a knack for turning down roles that ended up making other actors famous. He already had Bond and Han Solo on that list before this one came along. The role in question was Edward Lewis in Pretty Woman. Richard Gere stepped in, and that movie has become one of the first titles on pretty much every best rom-com list. Reynolds spent that time filming Modern Love, a small Robby Benson movie that barely made a ripple.
Pretty Woman eventually crossed $450 million worldwide, turned Julia Roberts into a household name, and landed her an Oscar nomination. In his 2015 memoir, But Enough About Me, Reynolds admits that he turned down the role without much thought, but ultimately regretted it after finally watching the movie. He wrote, “Then I watched the movie the other night and thought, ‘Damn, Julia Roberts!’ What the hell was I thinking?”
3. Emily Blunt (Iron Man 2 for Gulliver’s Travels)
Jon Favreau, the director of Iron Man 2, originally wanted Emily Blunt as Natasha Romanoff, aka Black Widow. Not Scarlett Johansson. Blunt likely would have snatched the opportunity, because she later admitted that losing the role was “a bit of a heartbreaker” for her. There was just one problem: a contract with 20th Century Fox from years earlier still had her on the hook for one more movie. That movie turned out to be Gulliver’s Travels, the same Jack Black comedy that critics tore to shreds. Johansson landed the role and spent the next decade making Marvel history before getting that heart-breaking sendoff in Avengers: Endgame.
4. William Hurt (Jurassic Park for Mr. Wonderful)
William Hurt was already an Oscar winner known for prestige dramas like Kiss of the Spider Woman and Broadcast News. So it made perfect sense that Steven Spielberg turned to him for the role of Dr. Alan Grant after Harrison Ford rejected him. But Hurt also read the Jurassic Park script and said no. That year, he went on to do Mr. Wonderful (1993), a rom-com that scraped up $3 million against a $13 million budget. Not exactly a hit.
Sam Neill, the actor who later portrayed Dr. Grant with such emotional depth, only got the call just weeks before filming started. This makes his performance even more impressive. Jurassic Park became the highest-grossing movie in 1993, rewrote the rules of CGI, and spawned a franchise that’s still making waves today. Hurt’s name rarely comes up in the conversation anymore.
5. Sean Connery (The Lord of the Rings for The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen)
Sean Connery read the book. He read the movie script. He even watched the finished trilogy later. By his own admission, none of it ever made sense to him, and that’s why he never played Gandalf. Playing a wizard was apparently a bridge too far for a man who survived Highlander sequels. But okay. Ian McKellen got the part instead, along with a deal that would have netted Connery $450 million if he’d taken it.
He went with The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, a steampunk mashup about Victorian misfits fighting masked villains. Connery called the shoot a nightmare, and it became his last live-action role. The Rings trilogy went on to gross nearly $3 billion, with The Return of the King alone taking home all 11 Oscars it was nominated for. Connery never seemed to regret it, saying only that McKellen did a fine job.
Follow Us





