Dune was reintroduced to audiences in a 2021 remake, with a sequel from director Denis Villeneuve in the works. In 1984, David Lynch embarked on a monumental task — translating Frank Herbert‘s science fiction tour de force into a movie. His initial cut was over 14 hours long and needed substantial editing. This left the version moviegoers saw in need of extensive explanation. The original Dune film undeniably served as a cinematic spectacle of its era.
Denis Villeneuve took up the challenge to recreate the book that many believed couldn’t be accurately portrayed in the film. However, his version of Dune turned out to be extraordinary. Unlike Lynch, Villeneuve did not attempt to condense the whole book into one film. Instead, he opted to divide it into two segments. Viewers immediately observed substantial stylistic discrepancies between the 2021 and 1984 Dune. Regardless, both Lynch and Villeneuve have been praised for their remarkable adaptions of Herbert’s narrative to the big screen.
Timothée Chalamet Vs. Kyle Maclachlan as Paul Atreides
Kyle MacLachlan portrayed Paul Atreides in the 1984 version of Dune. He presented a more mature and analytical character, showcasing strong leadership skills and charisma. His portrayal employed voiceovers to convey the character’s internal monologues, a significant element of Herbert’s original novel. This approach made the 1984 film a more direct narrative, with Paul’s transformation into a leader unfolding rapidly.
Timothée Chalamet‘s portrayal of Paul in the 2021 version was more emotionally nuanced. It focused on Paul’s dark transformation from an entitled aristocrat to the planet’s messiah. Chalamet’s youthful performance offered a more faithful representation of Paul’s age as depicted in Herbert’s novel. That allowed the film to explore the character’s family dynamic and coming-of-age story in greater depth. His version also included Paul’s visions of a future jihad. This is a significant plot element that was omitted in the 1984 film.
Zendaya Vs. Sean Young as Chani
In the recent Dune adaptation, Zendaya‘s portrayal of Chani stands out with its depth and strength. In contrast to Sean Young‘s 1984 portrayal, Zendaya delves into the character’s nuances. She explores her way of living and navigating her home planet. Despite limited screen time in the first part of the film, she managed to deliver a memorable performance.
Sean Young, in the 1984 version, was somewhat limited by the script. Altogether, it positioned her character primarily as a love interest. This role offered little opportunity to explore Chani’s potential fully. On the other hand, Zendaya’s Chani, although briefly appearing in the first part of the new adaptation, was more memorable and impactful.
Oscar Isaac Vs. Jürgen Prochnow as Duke Leto
In the 2021 film adaptation, Oscar Isaac portrays the character of Duke Leto Atreides. This Dune character is described as a fatherly figure that embodies nobility and humanity. Isaac emphasizes Leto’s complicated circumstances as he navigates the perils of moving his family to the desert planet of Arrakis. He portrays Leto as a man under intense pressure to protect his family and House.
Jürgen Prochnow played Duke Leto Atreides in the 1984 adaptation of Dune. It’s clear that the character of Duke Leto remains consistent as the head of House Atreides and father to Paul Atreides. In the 1984 film, Duke Leto is seen as a just and noble leader, hoping to ensure the flourishing of House Atreides. He is portrayed as a loving father and a man of integrity, always considering the welfare of his people and the future of his House.
Rebecca Ferguson Vs. Francesca Annis as Lady Jessica
Rebecca Ferguson brings a unique and modernized perspective to the role of Lady Jessica in the 2021 adaptation of Dune. Altogether, it contrasts with Francesca Annis‘ 1984 portrayal. In an interview with The Gate in 2021, Ferguson focused on the character’s role as a mother, saying, “It felt, you know, unique somehow, even though it’s a remake of a 1965 book, there was something just … because I got to modernize the feeling of being an annoyed mom with a kid as well.”
David Lynch’s vision largely shaped Annis’s performance in the 1984 version. Yet, Annis noted that the film’s aesthetic was affected by producer Dino De Laurentiis‘ oversight. Interestingly, the 1984 version stayed truer to the book’s description of Lady Jessica’s vibrant ginger hair color, while in the 2021 version, her hair appears brown.
Jason Momoa Vs. Richard Jordan as Duncan Idaho
Jason Momoa‘s portrayal of Duncan Idaho in the 2023 adaptation of Dune is highlighted by his charisma and warmth. He embodies a powerful swordmaster who is both a wise soldier and a source of comic relief. Momoa’s Duncan is a figure of empathy, standing at the intersection of two worlds: the noble House Atreides and the Fremen of Arrakis.
He is deeply respectful of the Fremen culture, distinguishing him from his fellow swordsmen. Momoa’s Duncan is a high-energy presence, whether he’s comforting Paul, cracking jokes, or heading into battle. His heroic and sacrificial stand during the siege on House Atreides further cements his memorable impact in the movie. In the 1984 adaptation of Dune, Richard Jordan played the role of Duncan Idaho. This character’s portrayal in the 1984 version was not as prominent or fleshed out.
The 1984 adaptation of Dune has been criticized for its confusing plot, unexplained or incomplete relationships, and overload of characters. The film was described as an “incomprehensible, ugly, unstructured, pointless excursion into the murkier realms of one of the most confusing screenplays of all time” by Roger Ebert.
Josh Brolin Vs. Patrick Steward as Gurney Halleck
In the 2021 version of Dune, Josh Brolin‘s Gurney Halleck is portrayed as the weapons master of House Atreides. He’s training Paul and protecting him during a critical rescue mission on Arrakis. Brolin brought depth to the character, reflecting his broad experience in a range of films. Conversely, the 1984 Dune features Patrick Stewart as Gurney Halleck, adding a unique Shakespearean gravitas to the role. Stewart, famous for Star Trek: The Next Generation and the X-Men series, infused his part with a distinct theatrical weightiness. His classical training provided a different layer of complexity to the character, making his performance stand out in its own way.
Javier Bardem Vs. Everett McGill as Stilgar
Everett McGill portrayed Stilgar as a secondary protagonist in the 1984 version of Dune. McGill’s Stilgar was a formidable Fremen warrior who rose to become the leader of the local Fremen community on Arrakis. After witnessing Paul Atreides’ combat abilities, Stilgar grants Paul and his mother sanctuary. He also gives Paul the secret name of Usul.
Throughout the film, Stilgar serves as Paul’s right hand, assisting in various plans and battles. He is impressed by Paul’s strength, particularly when he takes the water of life and confronts Feyd Rathua-Harkonnen. Javier Bardem‘s portrayal of Stilgar in the 2021 Dune film is described as more accepting of Paul and his unusual mother. Bardem’s Stilgar believes in Paul’s prophetic figure and slowly keeps him under his wing. As Paul integrates more into the Fremen culture, Stilgar feels they are walking in the right way. His performance adds color and life to a character that could have been very severe.
Stellan Skarsgård Vs. Kenneth McMillan as Baron Vladimir Harkonnen
Kenneth McMillan, in Lynch’s 1984 adaptation of Dune, brings the character of Baron Vladimir Harkonnen to life. An over-the-top demeanor characterizes his performance. McMillan’s Baron is an outrageous presence, characterized by his intense lust for power and control. He revels in his schemes and manipulations.
But alternatively, Stellan Skarsgård‘s portrayal of Baron Harkonnen in Villeneuve’s adaptation presents a more restrained and intimidating figure. Skarsgård’s Baron is a thinking, calculating character with a depth and tension that director Villeneuve found lacking. Skarsgård’s performance is described as an unforgettable antagonist with the eccentric sci-fi villainy of Jabba the Hutt and the disturbing depth of Colonel Kurtz. His Baron Harkonnen is not just a massive figure of ugly lechery but a character with imposing features.
Dave Bautista Vs. Paul Smith as Glossu Rabban
Dave Bautista‘s portrayal of Glossu Rabban in the 2021 adaptation of Dune marked a significant departure from his previous roles. Bautista delivered a particularly intimidating and ominous performance, relishing the opportunity to work with director Denis Villeneuve. This role gave Bautista a chance to delve into a deeper character and explore different aspects of his acting abilities. While the portrayal of Rabban in the 1984 adaptation by Paul Smith is less well-documented. Smith’s Rabban is introduced earlier in the narrative than in the original book. Even more, his demise is depicted differently. Rabban is arrested while en route to his ship and is later shown beheaded.
Chang Chen Vs. Dean Stockwell as Dr. Wellington Yueh
Chang Chen portrays Dr. Wellington Yueh in the 2021 adaptation. The character of Wellington Yueh is a complex figure, having to make difficult choices as the narrative unfolds. Villeneuve’s casting of an Asian actor for a character implied to be of Asian descent in the source material signified a strive for authenticity. Chen’s portrayal leans into the complexities of his character.
The 1984 adaptation cast Dean Stockwell as Dr. Wellington Yueh. Stockwell’s performance managed to convey Yueh’s remorse well, emphasizing the character’s reluctant betrayal. His portrayal of Yueh was marked by a sense of regret that resonates with the audience. This focus on remorse provided a contrasting perspective to Chang Chen’s portrayal, adding a layer of emotional depth to the character.
David Dastmalchian vs Brad Dourif as Piter De Vries
In the 1984 version of Dune, Brad Dourif portrayed Piter De Vries as the cunning political advisor to the House Harkonnen. The 2021 adaptation has David Dastmalchian in the role of Piter De Vries, a character he described as “a human-computer and right-hand man of the monstrous Baron Harkonnen.” Drawing inspiration from the original book but consciously deciding not to look at any previous film adaptations, Dastmalchian crafted his own unique take on Piter. He saw his version of the character as a hybrid of HAL 9000 from 2001: A Space Odyssey, Bib Fortuna from Star Wars, and Toht from Raiders of the Lost Ark. Despite the same character name, the portrayals by Dourif and Dastmalchian illustrate two distinct interpretations.
Follow Us
