Hoarders are individuals who experience distress when parting with their possessions, regardless of the reason. While some cases are mild, resulting in a cluttered home, others can have severe consequences on a person’s personal and professional life. The exact causes of hoarding remain unclear, but it has been linked to stress, indecisiveness, and even family influence. Although hoarding can be treated, many hoarders may not recognize it as a problem.
It’s no surprise that hoarding has inspired several unscripted TV series, such as A&E’s Hoarders, which focuses on individuals facing imminent crises due to their compulsive hoarding. However, some may question whether the show is harmful to real-life hoarders, which is worth exploring.
Does A&E’s ‘Hoarders’ Negatively Affect Real Life Hoarders?
Hoarders appears to be more authentic than many other so-called unscripted shows. The participants are real hoarders, chosen from submissions sent in by their friends and family members. The show also features actual therapists, psychologists, and professional organizers who contribute based on their expertise and experience. Moreover, the assistance provided by Hoarders to its participants is genuine, although its effectiveness may not be 100%.
Based on this information, it’s reasonable to say that Hoarders is less exploitative than many other unscripted shows. The producers don’t pay the participants, except for the help they receive, which means they aren’t incentivizing harmful behavior. Additionally, while the show isn’t perfect, it treats its subjects with a fair amount of respect, unlike other unscripted shows that often portray their subjects as freakish curiosities.
As for the impact of Hoarders on real-life hoarders, it’s difficult to determine. The show may have a positive effect by raising awareness about the issue. Since many hoarders don’t recognize their behavior as problematic, watching Hoarders could help them realize the severity of their situation and seek help. Alternatively, the show could inform friends and family members of hoarders about the issue, potentially leading to intervention and support.
However, it’s easy to see how a less sensitive unscripted show on the same topic could negatively affect real-life hoarders. Many hoarders already struggle with unresolved stress in their lives, and adding more pressure could further harm their mental health.
Follow Us
