5 Movies That Prove Internet Hype Doesn’t Always Translate to Box Office Success

The internet has major power and influence, especially on how movies are made and released. A well-placed hashtag can be the difference between a movie that hits a billion dollars at the box office and another that barely breaks even. Internet hype, however, doesn’t always translate to box office success.

Every film on this list had to come to terms with that fact. Every single one of them had all the online noise they could ask for. Some of that hype was real and earned, and some of it was just people goofing around on the internet. Either way, they all had the same thing in common: all those tweets and posts didn’t add up to impressive ticket sales.

1. Snakes on a Plane (2006)

Samuel L. Jackson signed on for Snakes on a Plane for one of the most basic reasons to accept a movie role: he liked the title. Apparently, most movie lovers did, too. In fact, that love for the title led New Line Cinema to scrap plans to change the title to something “more serious.” That same pressure pushed for an R rating and one specific line, forcing five extra days of reshoots so Jackson could drop that infamous line about “motherf***ing snakes on a motherf***ing plane.”

Keep in mind this was the 2000s, long before “ironic internet hype” became a thing, so the studio thought they were sitting on gold. Their belief was further strengthened when industry experts predicted a $20 to $30 million opening weekend. Instead, the movie scraped in about $15.5 million. By the time it limped out of theaters, Snakes on a Plane topped off at $34 million in the U.S., and about $62 million worldwide against a budget of $33 million. Not a total wipeout, but nowhere near the financial payout everyone expected.

5 Movies That Prove Internet Hype Doesn’t Always Translate to Box Office Success

2. Grindhouse (2007)

Grindhouse opened against Are We Done Yet?, a family comedy about a newlywed couple who leave the city for a chaotic home renovation in the suburbs, and still lost. Let that sink in. That flop is made even worse by the fact that the movie had everything horror nerds had been drooling about for years. It had Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez teaming up for a three-hour double feature stuffed with fake trailers and worn-out film effects. The buzz was deafening, and again, “experts” latched onto that buzz to predict a $20 million opening weekend.

They were disappointed, of course, because the movie pulled in just $11.6 million that opening weekend, and it barely scratched the $25 million mark domestically, all against a $67 million budget. Overseas distributors panicked and chopped it into two separate films, which only confused everyone more. The one silver lining in this box office dud is that it gave birth to the Machete franchise.

3. Morbius (2022)

When Morbius first dropped in April 2022, critics tore it apart. Nevertheless, audiences still showed up and pushed the film past its own studio projections ($39 million on the opening weekend against the studio’s $33 million). A few months later, though, the internet gave it a second life with the “It’s Morbin’ Time” meme that became the go-to punchline for everything, even though it was borrowed from Power Rangers. The joke was that the movie was so awkward it was funny.

And wow, did that joke spread! Sony saw the flood of memes and convinced themselves that people actually wanted more. So they put Morbius back in over a thousand theaters, probably patting themselves on the back the whole time. It managed to scrape together $300,000 that weekend. Against a theater count that big, that figure was just… appalling. Clearly, Sony had misread a joke as real demand, and the box office gave them a very expensive lesson.

4. The Flash (2023)

Michael Keaton putting on the Batman cowl again after nearly 30 years felt like lightning in a bottle. Fans were thrilled and showed just how much with several Multiverse storylines, Comic-Con hype, and endless YouTube breakdowns. All that buzz pointed to The Flash being a hit. It didn’t translate to the box office. The opening weekend brought in $55 million, just a little over half the projected $100 million. That disappointment was followed by an even bigger one, as the movie crashed harder than any other DC movie before it by dropping over 72% in the second weekend.

Warner Bros. had sunk about $200 million into production and another $150 million into marketing, so they needed roughly $400 million globally to break even. They got $271 million. Analysts called it the biggest financial loss a superhero movie has ever incurred. Director Andy Muschietti later admitted that audiences, especially women, didn’t care about the character. DC rebooted the franchise soon after and started afresh with James Gunn.

5. Megalopolis (2024)

Francis Ford Coppola spent 40 years trying to get Megalopolis made. He even sold off part of his winery to fund it with $120 million of his own cash. Film buffs had been salivating over the project for decades and certainly expected more than the marketing team’s gaffe of dropping a trailer with fake critic quotes, some of which looked AI-generated. Sure, they pulled it within a day and apologized, but the damage had already been done. The movie pulled in just $4 million in the U.S. in the opening weekend before finishing at just over $14 million worldwide. Against that enormous $120 million budget, that figure looks like a rounding error.