We are in the weeks leading up to Thanksgiving, and kitchens across the country are getting ready for potluck season. Group chats are asking who’s bringing the rolls, and somebody’s cousin has already volunteered to “just throw something together.” Nobody stops to ask what that something is being thrown together on.
The “This Is Why I Don’t Host Potluck” Facebook group is spoiled for content this time of year, and it’s here to remind us that what happens in other people’s kitchens is a dark mystery. Members post photos of stovetops that should be condemned and meals that deserve a warning label. Think of this as your preview before you sign up for the green bean casserole. Scroll on, but put the snack down first.
#1

Image source: Makayla Tavares Greeson
#2

Image source: Anna Nikki
#3

Image source: ScuzzyTrashPanda
The word potluck goes back to the 1500s, when it meant whatever happened to be in the pot when an unexpected guest turned up for dinner. The luck belonged to the guest. It has nothing to do with the potlatch ceremonies of the Pacific Northwest, a mix-up people make all the time. Four centuries later, the guest still takes the gamble, and now they also have to carry the pot.
And luck really might not be on your side. The CDC estimates that 48 million Americans get sick from food every year, around 128,000 end up in the hospital, and for about 3,000, that was their last meal. Restaurants get inspected, and in some cities they have to post a letter grade in the window, so you know where you stand. Nobody has ever sent an inspector to your coworker’s house, so her kitchen runs on her own confidence.
#4

Image source: Anonymous member
#5

Image source: Emily Anderson
#6

Image source: Soren Hahn
Bacteria are a big part of that. The USDA says they multiply fastest between 40°F and 140°F and can double in as little as 20 minutes, which is why cooked food shouldn’t sit out for more than two hours, or one hour if it’s above 90°F. A potluck table at 1 pm on a warm day is a laboratory with a seating plan.
The CDC even calls Clostridium perfringens the ‘buffet germ’, and it causes about a million illnesses a year in the US. It loves big pots of gravy that cool too slowly, so asking “is the gravy supposed to be this temperature?” is a very good question.
#7

Image source: Rick Scott
#8
This is handy if that is the only time you need your teeth, I guess…idk

Image source: Anonymous member
#9

Image source: Katrina Guandique
Hands matter just as much. The CDC says infected food workers cause roughly 70% of the norovirus outbreaks linked to contaminated food, and that washing for 20 seconds prevents about 1 in 3 diarrheal illnesses.
The famous case is Mary Mallon, a cook in early 1900s New York who carried typhoid without ever feeling sick. She infected at least 51 people, and three of them lost their lives because of it. She insisted she was healthy and went back to cooking after being released, which is exactly what your friend with the cough says before bringing the deviled eggs.
#10

Image source: Alison Hill
#11
Toast anyone?

Image source: Anonymous member
#12

Image source: Anonymous member
A big culprit also sits in the kitchen sink (if it even gets used at all). A 2017 study found up to 54 billion bacteria per cubic centimeter in used kitchen sponges. The researchers also found that sponges people regularly cleaned weren’t any less bacterial than the ones they didn’t, so the scrubbing might just be moving things around.
Meanwhile, Rutgers researchers tested the five-second rule in 2016 and found that bacteria can transfer from a floor in less than one second. Watermelon picked up the most, and gummy candy picked up the least. Suddenly, gummy clusters for dinner doesn’t sound half bad.
#13

Image source: Shirley Kwan
#14

Image source: Anonymous member
#15

Image source: Esen Millington
If the photos in this group make your stomach turn, that’s a built-in safety feature in your brain. A psychologist at the University of Pennsylvania spent decades studying disgust and found that people refused to drink juice after a sterilized cockroach had been dipped in it. They also refused to eat fudge shaped like dog dodo, even though they knew it was fudge.
Valerie Curtis, who studies disgust at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, argues that the reaction evolved to keep us away from disease. Because of this, our gag reflex has a better safety record than most health inspectors.
#16

Image source: Katie Wohlford
#17

Image source: Anonymous member
#18

Image source: Anonymous member
None of this has stopped Americans from loving the potluck dish that started as a corporate recipe. Dorcas Reilly, a home economist in the Campbell Soup Company’s test kitchen in New Jersey, created the green bean casserole in 1955. It has six ingredients and needs almost no cooking skill, and her original recipe card is now held by the National Archives. Campbell’s says it appears on roughly 20 million American tables every Thanksgiving. The dish itself might be fine, but that doesn’t account for the kitchen it came out of.
#19

Image source: Anonymous member
#20

Image source: Alice Rain
#21
Thawing porkchops for dinner 🫣

Image source: Kelly Wilson
If you do end up at the table, the rules are simple. The USDA says leftovers should go in the fridge within two hours and be eaten within three to four days. Turkey needs about 24 hours of fridge thawing for every 4 to 5 pounds, which is why the Butterball Turkey Talk-Line, launched in 1981 with six home economists, still takes over 100,000 calls every holiday season.
There’s no hotline for the dip in the corner, and whoever brought it will be standing right there while you decide. So stay safe out there, folks, and stick with the food that arrives in a store-bought container.
Which potluck dish gives you the greatest reason for concern? Share your warnings with us in the comments!
#22

Image source: Jill Ian
#23

Image source: Jill Ian
#24
I guess at least the inner part isn’t in it 😬

Image source: CuriousReindeer9021
#25

Image source: Anonymous member
#26
Thought it was cute til I noticed the litter box at the bottom of the pantry

Image source: Rachel Bayliss
#27
Found this in the messy houses group

Image source: Anonymous member
#28

Image source: Anonymous member
#29

Image source: Anonymous member
#30
Another pesto monstrosity found in another group 🫠

Image source: Cassandra Humphreys
#31

Image source: Anonymous member
#32

Image source: Anonymous member
#33

Image source: Lindsey Ford
#34
I saw this in the Messy Houses Zooming group

Image source: Anonymous member
#35

Image source: Anonymous member
#36

Image source: Heidi Elson
#37

Image source: SwiftTurtle1494
#38

Image source: Brandi Fink
#39

Image source: Adam Browne
#40

Image source: ThoughtfulPomelo7039
#41

Image source: Skylar Howell
#42

Image source: Ashley Elder
#43

Image source: Anonymous member
#44

Image source: Anonymous member
#45

Image source: Allie Cheshier
Follow Us


