Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

Two’s company, three’s a crowd, as the saying goes. Anyone who has tried to pick a restaurant with a group of friends knows that each extra opinion makes the decision ten times harder. Now apply that to love and a shared calendar, and you can see why a throuple works like the ultimate group project. It runs smoothly when everyone pulls their weight, and the whole thing wobbles when someone treats the instructions as optional.

One man was browsing engagement rings when his girlfriend pitched a plan that changed his timeline completely. It came with ground rules and a lot of heartfelt talking, and only some of them stuck.

Being in a consensual relationship with two hot women sounds like any man’s dream, but the rules can get sticky, quickly

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

kues1 / Magnific (not the actual photo)

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

One man was happily in a long-term relationship until his girlfriend suggested they both start dating her best friend from college

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

magnific / Magnific (not the actual photo)

At first he thought it was a prank, but both women agreed they were attracted to him and each other, and had previously been intimate

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

lookstudio / Magnific (not the actual photo)

He was left confused and toiling with his emotions, unsure if this was a safe thing for his current relationship

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

magnific / Magnific (not the actual photo)

He was weary of his girlfriend’s friend’s dating history, and even though he loved her a s afriend, he didn’t know if it could be more

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

LetsAllDate

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

Camandona / Magnific (not the actual photo)

People in the comments urged him to talk to his girlfriend at length, and suggested some of the most important questions he needed to ask

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

stockking / Magnific (not the actual photo)

He returned soon after a long talk with both girls, explaining that they had spoken about the rules and how things would work

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

magnific / Magnific (not the actual photo)

They all agreed that they would all date each other, and that bringing someone else in would be considered cheating

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

magnific / Magnific (not the actual photo)

He also said he wanted to wait to be intimate, because for him it felt like a completely new relationship

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

LetsAllDate

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

magnific / Magnific (not the actual photo)

Commenters applauded him for his thorough discussion with the women, but also highlighted that there were still more questions to be answered

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

stockking / Magnific (not the actual photo)

Only a week later, he returned with an update after his brother spotted him and the new girlfriend in public

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

Wavebreak Media / Magnific (not the actual photo)

His brother set up an intervention with his parents as they thought he was cheating on Jenna, his first girlfriend

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

The Yuri Arcurs Collection / Magnific (not the actual photo)

His parents were very confused about the news of the throuple, and his brother all but gave him a high-5

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

LetsAllDate

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

Drazen Zigic / Magnific (not the actual photo)

The intervention might have been a good thing, as people agreed that keeping it a secret makes things more complicated

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

namii9 / Magnific (not the actual photo)

Nine months later, he returned with a shocking update that people did not see coming

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

egoitz_bengoetxea / Magnific (not the actual photo)

Jenna had become distant towards them, and when probed, admitted she had hooked up with a collegue from work

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

LetsAllDate

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

Vitaly Gariev / Unsplash (not the actual photo)

He immediately broke up with her, and later ended things with Mia also, saying he wanted a clean slate

A 2017 study led by Justin Haupert found that about one in five single Americans had tried consensual non-monogamy at some point in their lives. So Jenna’s pitch was less exotic than it felt at the time, even if he was nervously browsing engagement rings when she made it.

Poly circles call what this trio was navigating a “V,” where one person (the hinge) dates two people who aren’t dating each other. Their goal was a full triad, which is the hardest version to pull off, because a wobble in any one pairing rattles the other two.

Credit where it’s due: this guy did a lot right. He asked for a long talk before saying yes, made a list of questions, read the books Reddit recommended, and put intimacy on hold. Early romance floods the brain with feel-good chemicals, and the poly community even has a name for the high, “new relationship energy.” The standard advice is to wait for it to settle before making big decisions, which is exactly what the hookup ban did.

Jenna also described how she’d feel seeing the two of them together as “turned on” and “thrilled.” Poly folks call that sort of joy over a partner’s happiness “compersion,” a word that traces back to a San Francisco commune called Kerista in the 1970s. Saying you’d feel it and actually feeling it turned out to be different things, but it was a promising start.

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too

eugeneshemyakin9 / Magnific (not the actual photo)

His family’s reaction wasn’t a surprise. A study by Terri Conley found that people rate monogamous couples more favorably across the board, including on trust, health, and relationship quality, even when there is no evidence behind those judgments. Psychologists call it the “monogamy halo.” His parents saw a cheating son, and anything he said short of a phone call to Jenna was going to sound like an excuse.

But their ground rules were clear: nobody outside the three of them, and anyone who stepped outside the group counted as cheating. In consensual non-monogamy, the agreement is what defines cheating, and breaking it is the same betrayal whether you have one partner or two.

A review by Rubel and Bogaert found that people in consensually non-monogamous relationships reported about the same relationship satisfaction as monogamous people. So being in a throuple was not the problem, the lie was.

So he went from two partners and a ring fund to a clean slate, and he is probably right that he needs one. If he ever dips a toe back in, the checklist writes itself: slow starts work, honesty counts for more than any rulebook, and agreements are only as good as the person who signs them.

In the comment section, people agreed it was best he walked away and started fresh

Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too
Guy Planning To Propose Is Stunned When His Girlfriend Asks If They Can Both Date Her Best Friend Too