Kevin Costner’s highly anticipated project, Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 1, marks the start of an ambitious four-film series exploring the expansion of the American West. While this grand narrative ambition is commendable, the execution, particularly in the initial installment, leaves much to be desired.
A Chaotic Start to a Grand Opus
The film attempts to weave together multiple storylines but often falls short due to inconsistent editing that muddles the narratives. As a result, it becomes challenging to discern how many of the numerous characters are interconnected, leading to a lack of coherent character development or narrative momentum.
Character Arcs Struggle for Depth
Costner’s film introduces three main story threads. The first involves Marigold (Abbey Lee), a former sex worker entangled in her landlord Lucy’s (Jena Malone) troubled past, seeking safety with Hayes Ellison, portrayed by Kevin Costner stars as Hayes Ellison in the movie Horizon: An American Saga
. The second follows Frances (Sienna Miller) and Lizzie (Georgia MacPhail), escaping after their community is devastated by Apaches under Lt. Trent Gephardt’s (Sam Worthington) protection. The third begins late into the film, featuring a wagon train led by Matthew (Luke Wilson) on the Santa Fe Trail.
Struggling for Continuity
The transitions between these story arcs lack fluidity, often leaving viewers confused. Particularly jarring is the time jump that skips crucial details, such as Marigold’s relationship with her husband and how they reunite despite being constantly on the move. Viewers are left guessing about critical emotional beats that could have deepened our connection to the characters.
A Lack of Narrative Urgency
The film’s pacing issues are compounded by its duration. At 181 minutes, Horizon: Chapter 1 feels less like a feature film and more like a condensed season of television, making it a laborious viewing experience. While films like Dances With Wolves
demonstrated Costner’s prowess with extended narratives focused on character-driven stories, Horizon: Chapter 1 highlights his struggles with sprawling epics.
Sidelined Native American Stories
The narrative threads involving Native American characters, such as Pionsenay (Owen Crow Shoe), lack depth and are only sporadically addressed. This superficial treatment diminishes what could have been compelling subplots and reflects a broader disinterest in fully engaging with these perspectives.
Casting Performance Overview
The performances do carry weight in certain moments. Luke Wilson portrays Matthew on the Santa Fe Trail in Horizon: An American Saga.
, offering a stern leader navigating treacherous journeys. Sienna Miller’s portrayal of Frances brings sincerity to her role as she grapples with loss and survival in dire circumstances. Despite these efforts, the fragmented storytelling undermines these performances.
A Montage Ending
The bizarre choice to conclude with a montage previewing future characters and plotlines, focusing on Giovanni Ribisi who doesn’t appear until this moment, sums up the audience’s readiness to move on from this uneven start. Rather than building anticipation for sequels, it highlights the missed opportunities within its own runtime.
Conclusion
Overall, while Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 1 takes bold strides with its vast scope and cast including ‘Georgia MacPhail stars as Lizzie alongside Sienna Miller in Horizon.‘
, it often stumbles under its own ambitions. The promise of forthcoming chapters may hold potential for redemption. At present, though, the film’s sprawling narrative ambitions are less an epic triumph and more an overextended prologue.
Follow Us
