Elizabeth Sankey’s 90-minute documentary Witches delves into the grim realities of postpartum mental illness, offering a raw testament on the subject. Premiering at the 2024 Tribeca Film Festival, this film juxtaposes personal anecdotes with historical context to highlight the stigmatized phenomenon many mothers face, yet it also ventures into tenuous territories linking historical witch trials to modern psychological suffering.
Insights from Personal Struggles
Sankey’s memoiristic approach is stark and poignant. She recounts her bout with suicidality and multiple hospital trips following her son’s birth, bringing a needed authenticity to the topic. Her frankness when discussing her experiences, including a stay at a psychiatric unit with her baby, serves to normalize issues that extend beyond simple baby blues.
Exploration of Postpartum Mental Health
The documentary shines brightest when grounded in reality. It explores postpartum depression’s impact through statistics and real-life stories, including well-known cases like Andrea Yates and Daksha Emson. The inclusion of Emson’s story—both harrowing and enlightening—provides critical perspectives from those who have navigated the throes of postpartum psychosis.
Visually Ethereal Yet Earnest
Sankey’s flair for visual storytelling is evident in the documentary’s whimsical sets and contrasting aesthetic styles. Utilizing evocative indoor sets awash in greens, purples, and celestial decor, she contrasts these elements against grim themes to create an ethereal yet grounded experience.
Historical Context and Sociocultural Analysis
While shedding light on women’s powerful historical association with witchcraft, the film traverses the precarious line between engaging history and speculative commentary. For instance, it posits that postpartum psychosis could explain why women confessed to cavorting with Satan during historical witch trials, albeit with scant rigorous evidence.
Sociopolitical Underpinnings
Sankey’s film attempts to unpack deeply rooted societal anxieties about powerful women through tropes of witches. However, it sometimes falls into cliched feminist rhetoric by suggesting patriarchal persecution without substantial supporting data.
A Mixed Conclusion on Effectiveness
The insights gleaned from real women’s harrowing postpartum experiences are significant contributors to the discussion around maternal mental health. If this documentary inspires more parents to seek help for dark thoughts following childbirth, it has achieved something important. Nonetheless, its attempt at blending personal essays with pop-history remains uneven.
Follow Us
