Ishana Night Shyamalan’s directorial debut, The Watchers, is a mix of promise and pitfalls. Known for her work on Apple’s Servant,
Shyamalan brings her skill for creating atmospheres of tension to this adaptation of A.M. Shine’s novel.
Setting the Stage
The film starts strongly, with Mina, played by Dakota Fanning, navigating the dark and misty forests of Ireland. As Mina’s narration reveals, these woods draw in lost souls who never escape. It’s an eerie prologue that segues into the main narrative in Galway.
Mina’s Journey
Mina’s life changes when she is assigned to transport a parrot to Belfast. A night out assuming a phony identity foreshadows her struggle with self-acceptance. Her journey takes an unexpected turn when her GPS malfunctions and her car fails her in the heart of the woods, only to disappear shortly after.
Stranded, Mina encounters other captives and learns of The Coop, a sanctuary with rules: stand before the two-way mirror at night for the Watchers, creatures whose wrath is triggered by disobedience.
An Uneasy Atmosphere
Shyamalan excels in generating unease through canny framing and sharp sound cues. Her directorial choices evoke a sense of voyeurism and fear as Mina grapples with the reality of being watched and controlled.
Despite its early strengths, the movie struggles to maintain coherence. As Mina defies rules to uncover truths about her captivity, intrigue mounts but resolution falters.
Plot Twists and Turns
The plot relies heavily on twists that initially engage but ultimately feel contrived. After a promising setup, the narrative’s progression becomes bogged down by explanations that detract from suspense. Mina’s discovery of old technology and attempts to create a surveillance system inject energy but lead to a conclusion that strains credulity.
The Story Unravels
The connection between the mythical Watchers and Mina’s personal dilemmas offers depth but also drags the story into melodrama. Dakota Fanning delivers a compelling performance reminiscent of her work in Netflix’s Ripley, but even her prowess can’t save Shyamalan’s script from excessive exposition in the final act.
The climax reveals backstory and lore that shed light on little-known CGI creatures, their ancient bond with humans, and strict rules governing their actions. This mythos, however, turns an intriguingly spooky tale into a laborious exposition-heavy saga, weakening its impact.
Follow Us
