Andrew McCarthy’s first documentary film, Brats, explores his deep-seated displeasure with the Brat Pack label that defined not just his career but a generation of young Hollywood actors. While there may be an expectation for an inside scoop, the film leans more towards a reflective passion project.
McCarthy begins by frankly stating, We were who you wanted to hang with, who you envied, who you wanted to party with.
This includes fellow stars like Molly Ringwald, Emilio Estevez, Judd Nelson, Ally Sheedy, Demi Moore, and Rob Lowe. The term Brat Pack, coined in a 1985 New York Magazine article by David Blum, marked the start of their notoriety and subsequent struggles.
Exploring the Brat Pack Legacy
Nearly four decades later, McCarthy grapples with the legacy of the Brat Pack. Focused more on addressing the moniker itself rather than the films that cemented their fame, McCarthy delves into discussions with former co-stars. Although his ongoing outrage might seem excessive today, it strikes as genuine amidst a culture where celebrities frequently encounter online trolls.
A Glimpse into Former Co-Stars’ Lives
McCarthy’s journey starts with a visit to Emilio Estevez. Despite sharing McCarthy’s anger over the Brat Pack label, Estevez remains composed and brief. Their interaction hints at deeper histories yet often fizzles before fully unfolding. Similarly, Ally Sheedy glows with positivity but sparsely discusses her difficult times.
Missed Opportunities for Deeper Insights
This pattern of light engagement continues throughout the documentary. Even Timothy Hutton’s relaxed demeanor and surprise passion for bee-keeping aren’t examined further. Notably, Molly Ringwald and Judd Nelson did not participate.
The Cultural Commentary
Demi Moore suggests McCarthy reframe his resentment while Malcolm Gladwell and Bret Easton Ellis offer sharp cultural insights. However, moments like these are sparse within the film’s narrative.
The Nostalgic Appeal
Despite its limited scope, Brats manages to draw nostalgia. **Simple Minds**’s iconic song “Don’t You (Forget About Me)” plays as expected, rekindling memories of beloved ‘80s films like The Breakfast Club.
While Andrew McCarthy’s documentary might lack depth in certain areas, it nonetheless revisits significant cultural touchstones that defined an iconic era for many fans.
Follow Us
