Pixar’s Chief Creative Officer Pete Docter has made it clear that the animation studio has no intentions of transforming their beloved animated classics into live-action versions anytime soon.
While discussing his inspirations and career influences during a recent interview, Docter shared his thoughts on the growing demand for live-action adaptations. No, this might bite me in the butt for saying it, but it sort of bothers me
, he admitted. I like making movies that are original and unique to themselves. To remake it, it’s not very interesting to me personally.
Josh O’Connor’s Campaign for Ratatouille
The conversation was partly sparked by a social media campaign championing actor Josh O’Connor to star in a live-action version of Pixar’s culinary masterpiece, Ratatouille. Josh O’Connor’s resemblance to the film’s lead human character, Alfredo Linguini, led fans to envision him perfect for the role.
Despite the enthusiasm from fans, Docter was quick to put the speculation to rest by emphasizing that such a project isn’t on Pixar’s horizon. He remarked that he wasn’t aware of the fan-driven campaign advocating for O’Connor’s casting.
Challenges of Live-Action Adaptations
In further elaboration, Docter discussed why translating animated narratives to live-action can be problematic. Using Pixar’s 2009 hit Up as an illustrative example, he highlighted the challenges involved: So much of what we create only works because of the rules of the (animated) world
, he explained.
The whimsical possibilities provided by animation allow audiences to accept fantastical elements more naturally. If you have a human walk into a house that floats, your mind goes, ‘Wait a second. Hold on.’
, noted Docter. However, in animated scenarios, viewers are more forgiving and can suspend disbelief with ease.
An Example from Ratatouille
This sentiment is well illustrated by scenes from Ratatouille. The unique bond between Alfredo Linguini and Remy, a rat with an extraordinary knack for cooking, is driven by animations’ distinct storytelling capabilities—a realism that wouldn’t translate seamlessly into live-action.
In closing his thoughts on live-action remakes, Docter remained firm about Pixar’s aim to stay true to its core: producing innovative and distinctive animated features that capture imaginations through their inherent creativity and originality.
Follow Us
