Pixar chief creative officer Pete Docter sheds light on why the animation giant is steering clear of live-action remakes. In a recent interview, he expressed his preference for originality over adaptations of existing properties. It sort of bothers me. I like making movies that are original and unique to themselves. To remake it, it’s not very interesting to me personally,
said Docter.
This stance is significant considering Pixar’s parent company, Disney, has been actively producing live-action versions of its animated classics. Recent years have seen the release of Aladdin, The Lion King, and Mulan, embracing a trend of nostalgia-driven content.
The topic came up when Docter was asked about the fan-casting of actor Josh O’Connor for a potential live-action version of Ratatouille. Docter responded with honesty, No, and this might bite me in the butt for saying it, but it sort of bothers me.
He elaborated that much of what makes Pixar’s films work are the expansive and imaginative rules within their animated worlds, making live-action adaptations challenging.
Original Stories Over Rehashes
Despite the commercial success Disney experiences with their live-action films, critics often point out that they lack the appeal of original storytelling. Karley Sider aptly noted, Instead of creating new and original films with new characters and storylines, Disney has recently chosen to play it safe by either recreating its own classic stories or producing unnecessary sequels.
Docter’s perspective highlights the core values Pixar maintains, striving for fresh narratives that resonate deeply with modern audiences. He emphasized how some elements vital to their stories don’t easily translate into live-action. If you have a human walk into a house that floats, your mind goes, ‘Wait a second. Hold on.’
said Docter.
The Magic in Animation
One crucial aspect of Pixar’s animation is the suspension of disbelief that typical animated features inspire. In Docter’s example, audiences readily accept whimsical premises like balloons lifting houses in Up. This would be harder to pull off convincingly in a live-action format.
Pushing Creative Boundaries
This ethos is echoed by various Pixar executives who stress their commitment to innovation. Steve Jobs and Ed Catmull famously said,The only thing we’re afraid of is complacency—feeling like we have it all figured out. We want you to come shake things up.
They welcome disruptive ideas that push creative boundaries while avoiding stagnation.
Bucking Trends with Inside Out 2
Pixar’s latest release, ‘Inside Out 2’, exemplifies this approach. Returning us to Riley’s mind as she navigates teenagerhood offers a blend of familiarity and new challenges. However, reception has been mixed; while some praise its thematic depth, others feel it doesn’t capture the emotional nuances of its predecessor.
This balance between originality and sequel production continues to differentiate Pixar from Disney’s more commercially driven strategies.
Follow Us
